A Translator’s view of al-Andalus: The social politics of translation and communication in the Mediterranean Middle Ages

Through discussion of Youssef Chahine’s film Destiny with background information from Rosa María Menocal’s book The Ornament of the World: How Muslims, Jews, and Christians Created a Culture of Tolerance in Medieval Spain, we’ll look at cross-cultural communication in the Middle Ages from the idealistic view of the people who helped make it happen—translators working closely with writers to help them bring messages to readers. Destiny, by Egyptian director Chahine, won the 50th Anniversary Prize at the Cannes festival in 1997. It begins in Toulouse at the autodafé of a translator and continues to examine similarly difficult conditions developing further south, in the Cordoba of Averroes’ time.


Purpose | Description | Structure | Who should attend?
Pre-meeting information | About the facilitator


Developers:

Irwin Temkin , destinyworkshops@yahoo.com
Mary Ellen Kerans, METworks@gmail.com

Facilitator:
Irwin Temkin
Date:
23 February 2007
Time:
17:30-21:00 h
Location
Institut Europeu de la Mediterrània, Carrer Girona 20, Barcelona.
Fee:
Not charge, but please register (pdf or Word). All participants must be members of MET (annual cost €30) before the workshop or join when registering. MET has special arrangements for admitting members of EASE and EMAME as guests and we are forging relationships with other groups-ask us if yours is included: METworkshops@gmail.com

Purpose

To discuss the role of the “Western Caliphate” of Cordoba (756-1031) in creating and transferring knowledge in the Mediterranean region and beyond.


Description

This discussion workshop and social event highlights the reason why al-Andalus is remembered as a historical Camelot of Mediterranean culture. We’ll briefly discuss how Cordoba’s golden age of culture came about and the city’s role in the production of knowledge in Arabic as the main international language for culture at that time. By medieval standards, Cordoba was a thriving multicultural, multilingual city whose writers produced books and translations that rivaled those of Baghdad and far outshone those of other European capitals—until Muslim fundamentalist sects spread northward from Africa. Chahine’s film Destiny shows Cordoba just as the Caliphate started to decline, when its ideals were still remembered by Cordobans who hoped the city would keep its place of cultural superiority.


Structure

Brief discussion of the film’s historical background, the rise and fall of the “Western Caliphate” based on Menocal’s work. Participants will have a chance to see excerpts from and discuss the themes in Destiny, the 1997 film by Egyptian filmmaker Youssef Chahine (Arabic with English subtitles). This is also a networking and social event—so there will be the chance to continue discussion informally afterwards. (If you haven’t had a chance to see the complete film yet, contact destinyworkshops@yahoo.com and we will tell you where you might be able to see it.)


Who should attend?

Anyone interested in Mediterranean cultural history or in viewing the translator’s role from a fresh perspective. This is also a chance for MET members to get to know each other.


Pre-meeting information

The film:

Destiny, by Egyptian filmmaker Youssef Chahine, is something special and needs to be personally experienced. Chahine is an accomplished director and establishes his mastery over sophisticated Western-style film making—and at other moments he makes unabashed use of a style akin to Hollywood musicals of the 1940s and 1950s. In other words, Destiny is sophisticated and polished in places, adopts an intentionally naif esthetic in others, and is full of surprises and real history.

Peter Keogh:

There's nothing like a burning heretic to grab your attention at the beginning of a movie.... Read more: http://www.weeklywire.com/ww/11-30-98/boston_movies_1.html

History and Cultural Background:

The very brief historical background information to the film will come mainly from Yale professor María Rosa Menocal’s 2002 book The Ornament of the World: How Muslims, Jews, and Christians Created a Culture of Tolerance in Medieval Spain (Boston: Little Brown).

A glance at reviews of the book will give you an idea of its messages:

.


About the facilitator

Irwin Temkin received his MA in TESOL at Teachers College, Columbia University and came to Barcelona in 1978. He currently works as an English instructor, teacher-trainer and translator. E-mail: destinyworkshops@yahoo.com